Skip to content 
If you’ve ever found yourself halfway through setting up a game of cribbage and suddenly thought, wait… how many pegs do we need again? you’re not alone. It sounds simple—pegs, board, deck, done. But cribbage, for all its charm, brings up more questions than people expect, especially when it comes to the cribbage board pegs FAQ.
What kind should you get? Where do you keep them? Do materials matter? Are all boards built the same? And why are there four pegs when only two players are playing?
This blog dives deep into those questions and more, breaking down everything you never knew you needed to know about cribbage pegs, board design, and how it all fits together. Whether you’re new to the game or just looking to upgrade to a custom work of playable art, let’s get into the nuts and bolts—literally—of what makes a cribbage game run smooth and feel special.
Let’s start with the most searched question: how many pegs in cribbage? Most people assume two—one for each player. Logical, right? But nope.
The correct number is four pegs—two per player.
Why? Because cribbage is all about progression. You use one peg to mark your current score and leapfrog the other to show your updated score after each turn. This keeps a visual record of the score from the previous round. That way, if someone messes up their math, the previous peg shows where they were before they moved. It’s a built-in error-checker that’s genius in its simplicity.
So if your board only comes with four pegs, that’s enough for two players. Playing with three? You’ll need six. Always keep spares. Pegs vanish like socks in a dryer.
Now that we’ve settled the number, let’s talk about the types of cribbage pegs you’ll run into and why they’re not all created equal.
There’s a surprising variety when it comes to cribbage peg materials. Here’s a quick rundown:
Sleek, durable, weighty in the hand. They glide into holes effortlessly and have that polished feel many players love. Great for formal or heirloom-style boards.
Classic, warm, and in tune with handmade boards. If you have a refined design shaped by nature, these complete the organic aesthetic.
Cheap and functional. They get the job done, but you might lose that tactile satisfaction you get from heavier materials.
Material matters more than just looks. It affects grip, weight, how snugly the pegs fit—and how satisfying it is to move them. Choosing the right type isn’t just about preference; it’s about how you want the game to feel.
If you’ve ever owned a board where pegs roll around in a drawer or get shoved into a Ziploc bag, you already know how frustrating poor peg storage can be.
A well-designed cribbage board includes a secure compartment for pegs. Some are magnetized drawers, some are hidden under a sliding panel, and some have a custom inlay beneath the board. This isn’t just about convenience—it’s about care.
Pegs without a home are the first things to get lost, and let’s face it, mismatched replacements ruin the vibe. A board with thoughtful peg storage shows the maker considered the whole experience—from start to finish. That’s the difference between a board you play and one you pass down.
Here’s one detail most people never think about until they hate their board: peg spacing.
If the holes are too close, moving pegs gets clumsy. If they’re uneven, it ruins the rhythm of the game. Cribbage isn’t just about scoring—it’s about flow. Pegs should move smoothly, with just enough resistance to stay in place but not so tight that you’re forcing them in.
Boards with proper peg spacing give you that satisfying “click” without the jam. It might sound like a small thing, but it’s these tiny details that separate a run-of-the-mill board from a custom work of playable art.
Want a quick test? If you can easily see the whole track from a seated position without squinting or counting holes twice—your board’s doing it right.
You’ve got the board. Now you’re wondering if your pegs are holding you back. Here’s how to do a smart cribbage peg comparison when shopping for new ones:
If you want to add personality to your setup, artisan peg makers offer sets that match the board’s tone and grain. You can even get a set that complements a board built with a refined design shaped by nature.
Time to answer a few lightning-round questions on cribbage rules for pegs that players ask all the time:
Sure. But once you’ve tried real pegs—especially metal or hardwood—those improvisations feel sad. Just keep extras on hand.
Technically, you can call a “muggins” and claim the extra points for yourself—if that’s your house rule. But it depends on who you’re playing with. Friendly or competitive?
Yes, ideally. Contrasting colors help avoid confusion during leapfrogging. No one wants to waste time asking, “Which peg is mine again?”
Absolutely. There’s a whole niche market for handcrafted pegs in brass, copper, even turned exotic woods. If your board has that expressive look with lasting charm, custom pegs only enhance it.
So how many pegs do you need? At least four. But what you really need is the right four. Cribbage isn’t just about winning—it’s about connection, nostalgia, and time spent face-to-face in a world full of screens. And every piece of the game should support that experience.
When you know what to look for—from peg materials to spacing, storage, and design—you’re no longer buying parts. You’re curating a ritual. One that starts the moment you open the drawer and pull out pegs that feel just right in your fingers.
Whether you’re new to cribbage or just ready to elevate your setup, it’s worth choosing pieces that reflect the kind of games you want to play—and the kind of memories you want to make.
So why not play with a board that tells a story? Because cribbage is more than just numbers. It’s heart, history, and home—one peg at a time.
Share :
Optimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
